22t: two-factor laws REFUTED by descent (quad Q->0, resrp rp->0 — geometry already in lvl=am/res); real render of sim-optimum 7.6/1.694 = 1.898 with group regressions, canon stays; error budget: dual = 62% of corpus abs-error -> inter-band acc/f6f8 consumer is priority #1

dsp/framed_model.cpp

@@ -245,6 +245,17 @@ static void process_band_structural(
         }
     }
 
+    // RT_RESPRP=1 (NOTES 22t): keep ONLY the res^rp factor of the warp cascade
+    // while NOWARP skips the full kBand768*kWarp*res^rp blanket. Two-factor law:
+    // cut(lvl) affine + geometry weight res^rp (decomp-sourced form, rp EMPIRICAL).
+    static const int resrp_only = getenv("RT_RESPRP") ? atoi(getenv("RT_RESPRP")) : 0;
+    if (nowarp && resrp_only) {
+        for (size_t k = 0; k < nbin; k++) {
+            double res_k = std::max(static_cast<double>(res[k]), 1e-12);
+            mask_out[k] *= std::pow(res_k, rp);
+        }
+    }
+
     // Step 9 (NOTES_LEVEL:830 + consumers_out.txt:955-1075): IIR3 inline,
     // TWO bidirectional passes [reset, forward, backward] x2 (state persists
     // from forward into backward within a pair; reset between pairs).
@@ -330,6 +341,11 @@ void FramedDetector::setParams(const std::vector<DetectorBand>& bands) {
     res_.clear();
     track_.clear();
 
+    // RT_DUMPRESPATH=<file> (NOTES 22t): static twin-response spectra per band,
+    // binary {int32 band, int32 nbin, float res[nbin]} records (append).
+    FILE* rp_dump = nullptr;
+    if (const char* dp = getenv("RT_DUMPRESPATH")) rp_dump = fopen(dp, "ab");
+
     for (const auto& b : bands_) {
         std::vector<float> r(half + 1, 1.0f);
         float sens_lin = std::pow(10.0f, b.sens * SENS_SCALE / 20.0f);
@@ -348,8 +364,16 @@ void FramedDetector::setParams(const std::vector<DetectorBand>& bands) {
             r[k] = std::sqrt(out[k].re * out[k].re + out[k].im * out[k].im);
             r[k] = std::max(r[k], 1e-12f);
         }
+        if (rp_dump) {
+            int32_t bi = static_cast<int32_t>(res_.size());
+            int32_t nb = static_cast<int32_t>(r.size());
+            fwrite(&bi, sizeof(int32_t), 1, rp_dump);
+            fwrite(&nb, sizeof(int32_t), 1, rp_dump);
+            fwrite(r.data(), sizeof(float), r.size(), rp_dump);
+        }
         res_.push_back(std::move(r));
     }
+    if (rp_dump) fclose(rp_dump);
     track_.assign(bands_.size(), std::vector<float>(half + 1, 1.0f));
 }
 

handoff/NOTES_LEVEL.md

@@ -2016,3 +2016,45 @@ x_i=−dA*/dS — точная эффективная координата ке
    не решается, подтверждено покейсовой бисекцией.
 3. Реплей-инфраструктура готова для быстрого перебора ЛЮБЫХ параметрических законов
    (2 c корпус) — использовать вместо реальных рендеров до финальной валидации.
+
+## ============ UPDATE 2026-08-23b (22t): ДВУХФАКТОРНЫЕ ЗАКОНЫ ОТВЕРГНУТЫ — БЮДЖЕТ ОШИБКИ В DUAL ============
+
+Инструменты расширены:
+- `RT_DUMPRESPATH=<file>` в FramedDetector::setParams — статические спектры twin-response
+  res[band][bin] ({i32 band,i32 nbin,f32[]}, append); lawfit collect кладёт их в npz рядом с lvl.
+- `RT_RESPRP=1` в process_band_structural — применять res^rp при NOWARP (для реальных
+  рендеров двухфакторного закона).
+- `lawfit22r.py fit`: координатный спуск по семействам законов на реплее (2 c/корпус).
+
+### Результат фит-семейств (офлайн, старт 7.6/1.6)
+| семейство | A | S | Q | rp | TOTAL(sim) |
+|-----------|---|---|---|----|-----------|
+| scalar | 7.600 | 1.694 | 0 | 0 | **1.860** |
+| quad (Q·x²) | →scalar | | **→0** | | 1.860 |
+| resrp (mask·res^rp) | →scalar | | | **→0** | 1.860 |
+| quad+resrp | 7.452 | 1.540 | +0.069 | 0 | 1.865 |
+
+ОБА вторых фактора отброшены спуском: кривизна не нужна, res-вес не нужен.
+Объяснение resrp: lvl = am/res УЖЕ содержит геометрию твин-юбки; домножение на
+res^rp сверху — двойной учёт (в каноне res^rp компенсировал другое — отсутствие
+res в xv-домене LUT).
+
+### Реальный рендер скалярного оптимума (7.6, 1.694)
+t1kq 0.954 / t1k 0.842 / al 0.799 / res **0.117** / dual **3.246** / comb 4.855
+⇒ TOTAL **1.898** (sim 1.860 + стат. смещения реплея ~0.04). Против HEAD 1.931:
+выигрыш мизерный, t1kq/t1k/comb РЕГРЕССИРУЮТ ⇒ гейт не пройден, канон НЕ тронут.
+
+### Бюджет ошибки — где лежит остаток (решающий факт)
+abs-сумма по корпусу при (7.6,1.694): 115.4 дБ·кейсов, из них:
+- **dual: 22 кейса × 3.246 = 71.4 (62%!)** — межполосный механизм (Шаг 2/9, консюмер acc/f6f8);
+- comb: 24.3 (21%) — мультиполосное взаимодействие;
+- всё прочее: ~20 (17%).
+Если бы dual был на уровне bridge (0.726), TOTAL упал бы до ~0.96. Никакая
+донастройка закона это не даст — ПРИОРИТЕТ №1 подтверждён количественно:
+искать точку потребления acc/f6f8 (межполосный каскад), а не крутить маску.
+
+### NEXT
+1. dual/межполосный консюмер: декомп-охота вокруг FUN_180529fe0 callers
+   (52e260 render-loop, multiband combine), трассировка acc/f6f8 в живом плагине.
+2. comb: после dual — пере-тест 4-полосного взаимодействия.
+3. Реплей-инфра готова; для любых новых гипотез сначала офлайн (2 c), потом рендер.

scripts/lawfit22r.py

@@ -91,10 +91,14 @@ def collect():
 
     store = {}
     traj_bin = '/tmp/opencode/lawfit_traj.bin'
+    resp_bin = '/tmp/opencode/lawfit_res.bin'
     for key, u in sorted(uniq.items()):
         if os.path.exists(traj_bin):
             os.remove(traj_bin)
-        env = {**os.environ, **BASE_ENV, 'RT_DUMP_ALL': traj_bin}
+        if os.path.exists(resp_bin):
+            os.remove(resp_bin)
+        env = {**os.environ, **BASE_ENV, 'RT_DUMP_ALL': traj_bin,
+               'RT_DUMPRESPATH': resp_bin}
         subprocess.run([corpus.RB, u['inp'], '/tmp/opencode/lawfit_out.wav'] + u['args'],
                        capture_output=True, text=True, env=env,
                        cwd='/home/m/re-tools')
@@ -104,9 +108,26 @@ def collect():
             continue
         lvl = arr.reshape(-1, u['nb'], RBIN)  # [frame][band][bin]
         store[key] = lvl
-        print(f'{key}: {lvl.shape[0]} frames x {u["nb"]} bands')
+        # static twin-response spectra per band ({i32 band, i32 nbin, f32[nbin]})
+        res = None
+        if os.path.exists(resp_bin):
+            raw = open(resp_bin, 'rb').read()
+            off = 0
+            bands = []
+            while off < len(raw):
+                bi, nb = struct.unpack_from('<ii', raw, off)
+                off += 8
+                r = np.frombuffer(raw, dtype='<f4', count=nb, offset=off)
+                off += 4 * nb
+                bands.append(r.astype(np.float32))
+            if len(bands) == u['nb'] and all(b.size == RBIN for b in bands):
+                res = np.stack(bands)
+        if res is not None:
+            store[key + '|res'] = res
+        print(f'{key}: {lvl.shape[0]} frames x {u["nb"]} bands'
+              + (' +res' if res is not None else ' NORES'))
     np.savez_compressed(TRAJ, **store)
-    print(f'\nwrote {len(store)} trajectories -> {TRAJ}')
+    print(f'\nwrote {len(store)} entries -> {TRAJ}')
 
 
 def load_traj():
@@ -135,16 +156,24 @@ class CaseInput:
         return lvl.shape[0] == self.nf
 
 
-def masks_from_lvl(lvl, nb, A, S):
+def masks_from_lvl(lvl, nb, A, S, Q=0.0, res=None, rp=0.0):
-    """Per-frame lower-half mask exactly as bare chain + LAWAFFINE produces."""
+    """Per-frame lower-half mask exactly as bare chain + LAWAFFINE produces.
+
+    Law families (22t): scalar cut=A+S*log2(lvl); quad adds curvature Q*x^2;
+    resrp multiplies per-band mask by res^rp (decomp warp-cascade factor,
+    applied BEFORE cross-band min like the C++ warp section).
+    """
     nf = lvl.shape[0]
     lv64 = lvl.astype(np.float64)
-    mm = np.exp2(-((A + S * np.log2(np.maximum(lv64, 1e-12))) / 6.0174))
+    x = np.log2(np.maximum(lv64, 1e-12))
+    mm = np.exp2(-((A + S * x + Q * x * x) / 6.0174))
     low = lv64 <= 1e-6                       # C++ fallback: exp2(-level)
     if low.any():
         mm[low] = np.exp2(-lv64[low])
+    if res is not None and rp:
+        mm = mm * res[None].astype(np.float64) ** rp
     if nb > 1:
-        lo = np.min(mm, axis=1)
+        lo = np.min(mm, axis=1)                 # min across bands
     else:
         lo = mm[:, 0, :]
     full = np.ones((nf, NFFT))
@@ -153,10 +182,10 @@ def masks_from_lvl(lvl, nb, A, S):
     return full
 
 
-def replay(ci, lvl, nb, A, S):
+def replay(ci, lvl, nb, A, S, Q=0.0, res=None, rp=0.0):
-    """Return trimmed 44.1k output for law (A,S) on prepared CaseInput ci."""
+    """Return trimmed 44.1k output for law params on prepared CaseInput ci."""
     assert ci.frames_ok(lvl), f'traj {lvl.shape[0]} != frames {ci.nf}'
-    full = masks_from_lvl(lvl, nb, A, S)
+    full = masks_from_lvl(lvl, nb, A, S, Q, res, rp)
     segs = ci.xext[ci.offs[:, None] + np.arange(NFFT)[None, :]] * _WIN[None, :]
     yspec = np.fft.fft(segs, axis=1) * full
     td = np.real(np.fft.ifft(yspec, axis=1))
@@ -203,20 +232,18 @@ def build_eval_index(trajs):
     return idx
 
 
-def sim_errors(trajs, idx, A, S, ref_cache=None):
+def sim_errors(trajs, idx, A, S, Q=0.0, rp=0.0):
     errs = {}
     ycache = {}
     for e in idx:
-        ck = (e['key'], e['nb'])
+        ck = (e['key'], e['nb'], round(Q, 6), round(rp, 6))
         if ck not in ycache:
             ci = case_input(e['key'], e['inp'])
-            ycache[ck] = replay(ci, trajs[e['key']], e['nb'], A, S)
+            ycache[ck] = replay(ci, trajs[e['key']], e['nb'], A, S,
+                                Q, trajs.get(e['key'] + '|res'), rp)
         y44 = ycache[ck]
-        if ref_cache is None:
+        errs[e['name']] = corpus.db(corpus.ta(y44, e['f'])) - \
-            errs[e['name']] = corpus.db(corpus.ta(y44, e['f'])) - \
+            corpus.db(corpus.ta(corpus.load_mono(e['ref']), e['f']))
-                corpus.db(corpus.ta(corpus.load_mono(e['ref']), e['f']))
-        else:
-            errs[e['name']] = corpus.db(corpus.ta(y44, e['f'])) - ref_cache[e['name']]
     return errs
 
 
@@ -250,45 +277,72 @@ def sanity(A, S, json_path):
 def fit(A0, S0):
     trajs = load_traj()
     idx = build_eval_index(trajs)
+    fit2(trajs, idx, A0, S0)
 
-    def objective(A, S, sub=None):
+
+def fit2(trajs, idx, A0, S0):
+    """Law-family comparison: scalar / quad / resrp / quad+resrp (NOTES 22t)."""
+
+    def objective(p, sub=None):
+        A, S, Q, rp = p
         ii = idx if sub is None else sub
-        return group_stats(sim_errors(trajs, ii, A, S))
+        return group_stats(sim_errors(trajs, ii, A, S, Q, rp))
 
-    best = (A0, S0)
+    def descend(p0, steps, sub=None, label=''):
-    bst = objective(*best)
+        best = list(p0)
-    print(f'start A={A0} S={S0}: TOTAL={bst["TOTAL"]:.3f}')
+        bst = objective(tuple(best), sub)
-    stepA, stepS = 0.8, 0.25
+        print(f'{label} start {[round(v, 4) for v in best]}: '
-    for it in range(4):
+              f'TOTAL={bst["TOTAL"]:.3f}', flush=True)
-        moved = False
+        while all(s > 1e-4 for s in steps.values()):
-        for A, S in [(best[0] + stepA, best[1]), (best[0] - stepA, best[1]),
+            moved = False
-                     (best[0], best[1] + stepS), (best[0], best[1] - stepS)]:
+            for i, nm in enumerate(['A', 'S', 'Q', 'rp']):
-            st = objective(A, S)
+                if nm not in steps:
-            mark = ''
+                    continue
-            if st['TOTAL'] < bst['TOTAL'] - 1e-4:
+                st = steps[nm]
-                best, bst = (A, S), st
+                for d in (+st, -st):
-                moved = True
+                    cand = list(best)
-                mark = ' *'
+                    cand[i] = round(cand[i] + d, 6)
-            print(f'  [{it}] A={A:+7.3f} S={S:+6.3f}: TOTAL={st["TOTAL"]:.3f}{mark}')
+                    if cand[3] < 0 or (nm == 'Q' and abs(cand[2]) > 3):
-        if not moved:
+                        continue
-            stepA /= 2
+                    s2 = objective(tuple(cand), sub)
-            stepS /= 2
+                    if s2['TOTAL'] < bst['TOTAL'] - 1e-4:
-        if stepA < 0.05:
+                        best, bst = cand, s2
-            break
+                        moved = True
-    print(f'\nBEST global: A={best[0]:.3f} S={best[1]:.3f} TOTAL={bst["TOTAL"]:.3f}')
+                        print(f'  {label} {nm}{d:+.4g}: TOTAL={s2["TOTAL"]:.3f} '
-    for k, v in bst.items():
+                              f'{[round(v, 4) for v in best]}', flush=True)
-        print(f'  {k:>6}: {v:.3f}')
+            if not moved:
+                for nm in steps:
+                    steps[nm] /= 2
+        return best, bst
 
-    print('\n=== per-group greedy optima (grid around global best) ===')
+    res_all = {}
-    for g in ['t1kq', 't1k', 'al', 'res', 'dual', 'comb']:
+
-        sub = [e for e in idx if e['grp'] == g]
+    b, t = descend([A0, S0, 0.0, 0.0], {'A': 0.4, 'S': 0.15}, label='[scalar]')
-        bA, bS, bval = None, None, 1e9
+    res_all['scalar'] = (list(b), dict(t))
-        for A in np.arange(best[0] - 2.5, best[0] + 2.51, 0.5):
+
-            for S in np.arange(max(0.25, best[1] - 1.0), best[1] + 1.01, 0.25):
+    bA, bS, _, _ = res_all['scalar'][0]
-                st = objective(float(A), float(S), sub)
+    b, t = descend([bA, bS, 0.0, 0.0], {'A': 0.3, 'S': 0.15, 'Q': 0.06},
-                if st[g] < bval:
+                   label='[quad]')
-                    bA, bS, bval = float(A), float(S), st[g]
+    res_all['quad'] = (list(b), dict(t))
-        print(f'{g:>6}: A={bA:6.2f} S={bS:5.2f}  mean|e|={bval:.3f}', flush=True)
+
+    b, t = descend([bA, bS, 0.0, 0.03], {'A': 0.3, 'S': 0.15, 'rp': 0.01},
+                   label='[resrp]')
+    res_all['resrp'] = (list(b), dict(t))
+
+    bA, bS, bQ, _ = res_all['quad'][0]
+    b, t = descend([bA, bS, bQ, 0.03], {'A': 0.25, 'S': 0.12, 'Q': 0.05,
+                                        'rp': 0.008}, label='[quad+resrp]')
+    res_all['quad+resrp'] = (list(b), dict(t))
+
+    print('\n================ LAW FAMILY SUMMARY ================')
+    for fam, (p, st) in res_all.items():
+        gs = ' '.join(f'{g}={st[g]:.3f}' for g in
+                      ['t1kq', 't1k', 'al', 'res', 'dual', 'comb'])
+        print(f'{fam:>12}: A={p[0]:7.3f} S={p[1]:6.3f} Q={p[2]:+6.3f} '
+              f'rp={p[3]:5.3f}  TOTAL={st["TOTAL"]:.3f}\n{"":>14}{gs}')
+    json.dump({f: {'params': p, 'groups': s} for f, (p, s) in res_all.items()},
+              open('/tmp/opencode/lawfit_fit2.json', 'w'), indent=1)
+    print('\nwrote /tmp/opencode/lawfit_fit2.json')
 
 
 def freq_of(name):